What a crisis at the BBC has to do with storytellers

It has been my recent pleasure to have a go at radio football commentary.  As a life-long fan of the beautiful game, this is bucket list stuff but it has also been thought provoking.  Reflecting on my commentaries, I wonder whether I have commentated on the game or a team and whether I have managed to remain neutral during the match.  Whilst I would like to say I have been fair, I am pretty sure I have made more than the odd comment which might suggest biased to the home team.  Maintaining a non-partisan position is an extremely difficult ambition particularly if you are passionate about the subject or event.  Human beings can display subconscious biased in their words and actions but can I be blamed if I get excited during my commentary when my team is up?  I’m pretty sure that taking a totally dispassionate position wouldn’t be much fun for me or the listeners.

As a student, I heard the phrase “History is written by the victors” used to describe how the widely accepted view how the world is chronicled.  This “Great Man” History as I have heard it termed, has been fed by creatives who played their part in colouring how we remember people and events.  The Bayeux Tapestry makes a famous impression of Harold’s death at the Battle of Hastings and William Shakespeare’s descriptions of Henry V and Richard III are entwined with accepted fact.  Conversely, for many, the First World War is summed up in the poetry of Siegfried Sassoon and Wilfred Owen.  As powerful and compelling as they maybe, these are viewpoints of people and events which must be considered through a wider lens if we are to find the truth of the story.

Stories have been shared for centuries with their content changing according to the purpose of the storyteller.  Within a moment of storytelling, the storyteller controls the narrative and once a willing audience is found, stories can take root.  In the modern world, all kinds of stories are told; stories about climate, migration and money told in powerful compelling ways.  These stories reach us day and night through a range of media; it’s easy to feel overwhelmed.  To protect ourselves, we learn to be suspicious of a story’s purpose, becoming aware of agendas and searching trusted sources.

For years, BBC News has been seen as a trusted source; an impartial institution in an ocean of dubious stories.  With its unique funding structure, which meant it didn’t have to bow to the demands of sponsorship and endorsements, it has sought to play Switzerland in the mire of misinformation.  Unfortunately, it seems that in reediting a significant story about American politics, trust in the BBC News’ impartiality has been severely affected and the damage done may take some repairing.  There are obviously other factors to what is a more complex news story but for an organisation to fall low because of a story’s presentation is a seismic moment for the importance of integrity in storytelling.

Fortunately, unlike the BBC, storytellers are not bound to be impartial.  We have thoughts, feelings and opinions and sharing those things is what makes a story worth hearing as they can appear to an audience as enthusiasm.  We grow up knowing that good stories can be trusted but in an increasingly saturated landscape the storyteller must work hard for their content to cut through – very few storytellers have the reputation or platform of an international organisation like the BBC but we are still advocates for our stories.  In a world of noise, storytellers are often in the privileged position of having the listener’s undivided attention; this and our story’s purpose should always be considered and respected (on and off the pitch).

John Kirk is a storyteller, Primary School Teacher and poet based in East Sussex.

Click here to browse John Kirk’s contributions to BBC Radio.